RNS Logo

rns.recipes

◈ 9ce92808be498e9e05590ff27cbfdfe4
https://rns.recipes/forum/general/important-security-notice-media-conversion-in-rngit-and-nomadnet

Reticulum Developer Summit 2026/27

Locked

Started by lava ·

#41

Just wanted to say that FOSS tends to go like this. Chill.

 

It is a remarkable achievement by Mark to create a tool/service/idea/concept that triggers others to jump on board with such whole-hearted gusto. This is because reticulum is a concept for its time: the time of privacy destruction and information theft.

 

I am all my life confronted with people who have good and (what I see as) bad ideas or behaviours. What defines humanity and social living is to focus on the good and deal non-destructively with the bad e.g. ignore, avoid, steer, engage, forgive, laugh, shrug. And note that one can have more in common than differences.

 

Reticulum and nomadnet pages are the only currently viable tools to regain what the information age was supposed to be for: communication in private by the people for the people. Reticulum gives the finger to tech bros' business model based on data theft and profiling and to hostile governments and their three letter agencies that seek to damage democracy. It is a Nobel Peace Prize level of significace long-run as it solves a problem at the core of Big Brother type abuse of our tech.

 

This is why it receives academic interest, and that is part of the way society has evolved to develop knowledge. If there is one thing worse than being talked about: it is not being talked about.

aetherlab Moderator 509723a0ccb60610...
edited #42

Oh, very eloquent! :) Laid out well. "Concept of it's time" is a nice anchor, and "whole-hearted gusto" truly brings lightness to it, and all of this in a single sentence!
I think we have another professor here!
And than comes the payload...
"What defines humanity and social living is to focus on the good and deal non-destructively with the bad e.g. ignore, avoid, steer, engage, forgive, laugh, shrug."

  1. "What defines humanity and social living is..." That is thick. Every human, society and culture derives these definitions for themselves. What's with the all encompassing approach? This is not what defines humanity for me, and for many more.
  2. Face away from the bad and do not focus on it. Bad is a constant, bad is all prevailing. Typical western construct, placing evil on a level, that is unreachable for humans, and placing good on the level of plain tradeoff - something to give away, to earn, to buy and sell. In my culture, Slavic one, we place good on that next level and accept evil as something within reach of all good men. In our tales we either destroy it, chase it away (search кукери online) or strike a deal with it, so it behaves. But we don't face away, ignore, avoid, forgive, or, God forbid - shrug at it.
  3. "It is a Nobel Peace Prize level of significace long-run as it solves a problem at the core of Big Brother type abuse of our tech." Oh, you also have feathers in that pocket! If we put aside the fact what Nobel invented and lived off and how many of those prizes were given off to people I would not associate any kind of peace with, RNS does not solve any problem by itself, like any other tool. People using it properly and in good will does. So this, if we read the words like gospel, is pointed in the wrong direction. But not really, is it? It is not meant to signify anything, it is meant to flatter Mark, and has a very nice counterweight, in the form of "Big Brother".
  4. "Reticulum gives the finger to tech bros' business model based on data theft and profiling and to hostile governments and their three letter agencies that seek to damage democracy."
    Oh, we have the whole package here!!! IT'S A BINGOOOOOU!!! We have the revolutionary call of Finger-Giving, the diminution of "tech bros'", the lack of comma after "model", that would just interrupt the flow of joy, the "true differentiation" between capital and state, between tech-business-data theft cluster and government-agency, the wild sin of democracy-damaging! This is a whole-milk-milk-shake! Very Hollywood-Tavistock vibey, joy to chew on and swallow. Most people tend to forget, that the Demos, that Kratos the masses in a Democracy, are not "THE PEOPLE", they were the citizens, the slave and land owners, in short THE OWNERS. They rule. They are the SUBJECT. All others are AN OBJECT.
    And this is why it is sooo aloowed to talk about ANYTHING ELSE but about ownership. God forbid PERSONAL one.
  5. Academia is nowhere to be found here. Interest comes from a very different vector. One that is well fed, supplied, informed and organized. And disruptive.
  6. "(what I see as) bad..." ah relativity rules...

 

But overall - amazing! We haven't had such text since the forum is up. It is on another level. Kudos! :)

#43

I am surprised that nobody mentioned yet that at the bottom of https://www.criticalinfralab.net/ are the logo of the Ford Foundation and the Open Technology Fund, who for its entire first years was 100% staffed with personnel from Radio Free Asia, itself funded by the US "Broadcasting Board of Governors" and previously 100% operated directly by the CIA... This may be seen as an even more disturbing interference than "just" power grab.

Rudi Mentaire 65e0ce50386e9c4e...
edited #44

My thoughts here are: It is, at least from the perspective of what I have read here, really, objectively irritating, how the organisers of this event failed, and fail, to coordinate with a big part of the community and the main developers, given the subjects they want to handle. But ok, I only have this perspective, maybe my impression is wrong.

 

But apart from that - isn't this already partly a discussion about the things that this conference is about? With a very relevant part of the community involved? Dear organisers, you should be able to handle this discussion here, because this is exactly what a relevant discussion just might look like.

 

And if you like to invite anyone, it is (at least in my world) your task to make people curious. It is typically not something one demands. Anyway, I'm afraid so far you have not been able to dispel some justified concerns of this important part of the community. And no, it is not due to academic language. It is, for example, calling valid concerns "strawman". I have, really, I'm quite new here, but I really have not the best impression, your invitation and the way it was presented here just were at least irritating. The reactions you got may be very sharp, but they are understandable.

aetherlab Moderator 509723a0ccb60610...
edited #45

gabuzo wrote:

I am surprised that nobody mentioned yet that at the bottom of https://www.criticalinfralab.net/ are the logo of the Ford Foundation and the Open Technology Fund, who for its entire first years was 100% staffed with personnel from Radio Free Asia, itself funded by the US "Broadcasting Board of Governors" and previously 100% operated directly by the CIA... This may be seen as an even more disturbing interference than "just" power grab.

 

Aaaaaaaaaa damn iiit!!! You outran me on this one haha! Cheers for the vigilance!
This is a very well funded nest of vipers and a classical informational warfare outfit and has to be taken very seriously.

zenith_2m_vhf_mobile 64f3482f6b30c2bc...
#46

This is why it receives academic interest, and that is part of the way society has This is why it receives academic interest, and that is part of the way society has evolved to develop knowledge.

 

Please go back and read the last two pages, that is not the issue here

Mees electronics bc848925e9890536...
edited #47

I live in a small village and we know our neighbors. We greet, talk and help each other out where needed. One day, a new neighbor moved in and on that first day she visited all the houses in the street. Not to introduce herself, but to tell us that she had started a whatsapp group for the neighborhood and we should all participate. We were flabbergasted and politely declined her offer. We told her that she could, instead, always knock on our door or call us if needed. We never heard from her again.

 

Should she have taken the time to get to know the local community first, I think things could have gone differently.

Nickie fe63e2eeb03bf3da...
#48

Rudi Mentaire wrote:

But ok, I only have this perspective, maybe my impression is wrong.

They are just looking to discover/pinpoint/recruit more "fellows" that may be sympathetic to their cause and sufficiently versed in the inner workings of RNS to establish their foothold here.

#49

aetherlab wrote:

gabuzo wrote:

I am surprised that nobody mentioned yet that at the bottom of https://www.criticalinfralab.net/ are the logo of the Ford Foundation and the Open Technology Fund, who for its entire first years was 100% staffed with personnel from Radio Free Asia, itself funded by the US "Broadcasting Board of Governors" and previously 100% operated directly by the CIA... This may be seen as an even more disturbing interference than "just" power grab.

Aaaaaaaaaa damn iiit!!! You outran me on this one haha! Cheers for the vigilance!
This is a very well funded nest of vipers and a classical informational warfare outfit and has to be taken very seriously.

 

It has actually been the primary tactic of the Open Technology Fund in the past: to gather all actors in one field, usually in a nice hotel on a beach resort (so as an extra benefit you have them leaving their laptops and other cryptographic material in their hotel room ;))) ) to have them to socialize, to get to trust you and to better exert "soft power" on them by infusing money and then only orally telling them "but don't work on this" or "do insist on such and such"...

 

Have you noted how no group working on "censorship", "internet filtering", etc. funded by the OTF has never named the USA as a main actor of Internet censorship, under the guise of copyright, code of conducts and other morality clause of a Google, Meta, Twitter. etc.?

 

It's almost a digression... but is it?

#50

Mees electronics wrote:

I live in a small village and we know our neighbors. We greet, talk and help each other out where needed. One day, a new neighbor moved in and on that first day she visited all the houses in the street. Not to introduce herself, but to tell us that she had started a whatsapp group for the neighborhood and we should all participate. We were flabbergasted and politely declined her offer. We told her that she could, instead, always knock on our door or call us if needed. We never heard from her again.

Should she have taken the time to get to know the local community first, I think things could have gone

 

I understand this analogy and I think if you had said this first (not saying it is on you) it would have been a slightly rough greeting, but it would have made plenty of sense to me anyways. I personally get why the original message was a bit ham-fisted or something if I put on my anti-establishment glasses, but there is immeasurably far worse in this world.

 

I spend time in a number of community groups and I have seen similar things happen to what you are describing. When someone enters a space without understanding the social customs it can stick out like a sore thumb (a crypto-bro entering a political tech critical space and looking for "collaborations with people interested in innovation" comes to mind). This said, the communities I am in (not perfectly) still aim to be courteous even if they might ask some pointed questions or be somewhat reserved/guarded. New people can't know the customs - they also do not always get the linguistic register for a situation correct (i.e. the phrases/words that people use in the office vs in the bar vs at a university etc.) or they are not a native English speaker so they use a word that gives the reader an impression that is not how the writer wanted to mean it. Communities that have a certain baseline kind of restraint as you say would politely decline or say "maybe this is not the community for you, maybe this or that space would make more sense to you".

 

But anyways it is a bit of a redundant point as a number of people here didn't react like the people in your small village. To continue the analogy, instead a bunch of people here pulled out the pitch-forks and yelled "it's a witch! burn them!". As you see above they started roughly speaking speculating about whether it was a CIA front / plant (which as an aside is precisely what a CIA plant would say :P - have you read the CIA simple sabotage manual?). One of the moderators appears to be the most troll like of all the participants in the thread which seems like the opposite of what I would want in that role.

 

The reason I am belaboring this is partly that there are some people up here by the North Sea who check this forum (the workshops even direct people to this place for info) and while maybe it comes to nothing bad in the long run, that kind of behavior can undermine cohesion/participation here etc. Hopefully I can persuade some of the pitch fork carriers with this message to change how they respond.

 

I like reticulum and I want to see it continue to grow (in an anti-capitalist sense). Certainly some people up here know or have met the people from the critical infra lab or the workshops (I am glad that people here seem to have at least separated the workshops from the lab in their mind) in one way or another as that is one of the ways people are introduced to reticulum. If they came across those messages, I think they would conclude from the disconnect of the responses from factual things they know that this (rns.recipes) is a community that has people who seem to rush to insults at a moments notice and has at least some people who make themselves feel good / important / smart by ridiculing others or denouncing them as spies. I say that even while I have my political differences with some things the critical infra lab do/write.

 

I also get that there seems to be a certain lingering trauma here from endless opportunists etc., slop-peddlers trying claim credit for reticulum by re-packaging it or get rich or whatever. I do get the reaction, not saying I always get things right either. Co-option sucks and I agree should be resisted, but I maybe a bit less heavy foot on the gas pedal at first?

 

Finally, I want to add that I appreciate @oakmilk!'s thoughts above about the syntax highlighting and some starting points to see what exist (if I can find the energy I was thinking about learning tree-sitter because then it could be used across at least several editors I think). Even if I think we might be hold some different ideas about the world but maybe could reach common ground in person, I appreciate their effort to try to shift things in a more constructive direction in response and clarify their original point.

oatmilk! 47829b93a57f1d41...
#51

bettertaste wrote:

[...]
Finally, I want to add that I appreciate @oakmilk!'s thoughts above about the syntax highlighting and some starting points to see what exist (if I can find the energy I was thinking about learning tree-sitter because then it could be used across at least several editors I think). Even if I think we might be hold some different ideas about the world but maybe could reach common ground in person, I appreciate their effort to try to shift things in a more constructive direction in response and clarify their original point.

 

yeah no, this has immediately lost any good will when you started accusing longtime community members of being the real feds. do not use me as an ally in your war of bullshit. take the L and move on to a different topic.

 

also,
https://rns.recipes/forum/off-topic/hello-mark-and-others-what-do-you-think-about-this-hunkajunk
is this bullshit y'all?

 

flok 3139c1fa6446992c...
#52

Ok I'm back on this.

 

Some of the stuff that stands out to me.

  1. confirmation bias
  2. cognitive dissonance around governance and control
  3. some of yall think very highly of yourselves

 

  1. Within what 20? 40 posts? we got to CIA allegations that are encouraged by one of the mods who's also writing wall of texts reading like a combination of a boomer facebook wall and high school philosophy. It's funny that aetherlab talks about "rigorous skepticism, hypothesis testing, and experimental validation" and them proceeds to call something they see for the first time in their life "a very well funded nest of vipers and a classical informational warfare outfit". Where is your hyphotesis testing and experimental validation? Are you too insecure to challenge your own biases? What if the opposite of what you think is true? That's the scientific method, no?

 

  1. I think there's a conflict between the take of "we already have a community" and "they're trying to establish control". It seems like you're clawing at the idea that rns.recipes needs to be the central point of organising around reticulum and any attempts at organising outside of it are co-optation.

 

Mark, you have reported in the past about your health problems and you're bringing up working 12-14 hours a day. How long can you keep going like this before you crash? What happens if you get hit by a bus tomorrow? Do we end up with 15 thousand AI-generated incompatible implementations? Who defines the protocol and how do we verify their credentials for it? Does reticulum die with you? Does it get overtaken by cryptobros? You are the central point of development and organisation for the protocol and I think it needs to be acknowledged. You have created something incredible and it deserves to be made resillient.

 

regarding institutional funding - yes it steers the grantees in certain directions. It's undeniably better to have lots of small donations to sustain developers. But after 10 years of development Mark is reporting to be getting around 1400$ a month, which is... fucking nothing? Why do you think we're getting all the slopware implementations? Most of us unfortunately have to work a fucking job and cannot dedicate their lives to doing community networks. Strategic, goal-oriented grant applications can benefit the community by paying developers to produce quality code, cover material costs of deployments. yeah maybe you can afford to shell out for radio gear, wifi antennas and lora boards but I can't say the same, and seeing how hard it is for Mark to get paid, I don't see money coming in for communities to pay for their deployments. Get out and touch grass people, most of us cannot afford or don't have the skills to read 200 page pdfs and buy little radio gizmos and if we want networks for the people, we need to make the infrastructures for it, we need to train people to use the networks and educate them about why those are important. If you want to build your homelab all power to you but to me reticulum is a political project and not a hobby. That means conscious social organising around it, rather than sitting in my mom's basement arguing with people on the mesh.

 

I don't see the issue in milking that sweet eu funding to get wifi links in my city. Unless you're hung up on being a starving artist, but I'm not in that business. And if all the development can happen without external funding, why is the funding a danger?

 

  1. I mean idk I think you have to be very full of yourself to think you can outsmart the CIA because you made some loose connections in your brain? Also the shit about taking your soul away or something, idk.
#53

Mark wrote:

It is truly painful to read these responses

If that is indeed the truth, I can understand that.

I'll invite you to see things from my perspective as well, in terms of pain felt. I don't think you have much idea about the actual, real pain, both phsyical and mental, that I am continously going through, while providing all of this.

And then having it shat on left and right, while still continuing to maintain and work dilligently for 12-14 hours a day, putting out release after release, while people keep posting and holding conference talks on the same shit about me not maintaining the project, et cetera, et cetera. How do you think that feels?

 

I'm sorry to hear that you have to go through all this. And I'm sorry that this message came across the way it did.

 

We build quite the community in and around NL in the last two years (as flok said, a travelling circus of people teaching mesh networking in autonomous communities, trying to find network equipment under every rock and turn it into a node and basically talk about reticulum to anyone who wants to hear), and worked hard to stay true to your intentions. We share your name, the zen of reticulum, and even this forum during the workshops. We avoid the LLM-slop as much as we can and we mostly focus on physical experiments with the tools you and others have build. We don't have much of an online presence, so not much to proof for it I guess. (Although it makes me happy to see the announces and the micron pages of all the friends we made along the way.)

 

We have been enthusiastic about Reticulum because of your intentions. Because we believe in them too.

edited #54

oatmilk! wrote:

yeah no, this has immediately lost any good will when you started accusing longtime community members of being the real feds. do not use me as an ally in your war of bullshit. take the L and move on to a different topic.

 

You read that entirely literally? yes a bit of cheeky of a comment from me given the absurdity of their comments but there is an joking emoji (:P) at the end for a bit of context - and what is your view of their behavior?

 

https://rns.recipes/forum/off-topic/hello-mark-and-others-what-do-you-think-about-this-hunkajunk
is this bullshit y'all?

 

No - never heard of it

Zenith Admin
edited #55

flok wrote:

Mark, you have reported in the past about your health problems and you're bringing up working 12-14 hours a day. How long can you keep going like this before you crash? What happens if you get hit by a bus tomorrow? Do we end up with 15 thousand AI-generated incompatible implementations? Who defines the protocol and how do we verify their credentials for it? Does reticulum die with you? Does it get overtaken by cryptobros? You are the central point of development and organisation for the protocol and I think it needs to be acknowledged. You have created something incredible and it deserves to be made resillient.

 

Hey, what if you DIED? You should give the control of the project over to us! We'll take care of it!

 

did that sound better in your head?

 

flok wrote:

. It seems like you're clawing at the idea that rns.recipes needs to be the central point of organising around reticulum and any attempts at organising outside of it are co-optation.

 

No one is saying this. There are dozens of Matrix channels, telegrams, etc, that people use for their own regional level organization. For example there is a TG channel for Reticulum Italy which has over 300 members last time I checked. You are free to go and setup whatever.

 

You are weaving around the actual point of contention which is the opposition to an "official Reticulum Governance Foundation" or whatever. Please read the last two pages.

edited #56

Zenith wrote:

Hey, what if you DIED? You should give the control of the project over to us! We'll take care of it!

 

Zenith wrote:

did that sound better in your head?

 

I am going to (should! :') ) probably give this thread a rest soon as I feel I have said my piece, but how you have made that post makes it look like a quote attributed to @flok, but it is your interpretation of what they are saying and so your comment about whether it sounded better in their head is responding to your own interpretation which is a negative meaning given to what they are saying. It is not what @flok said.

 

I went back to the survey and no where do they use the phrase official Reticulum Governance Foundation being set up. I do get why people are bristly at the idea/wording of "a reticulum foundation". I know it seems pedantic, but to the extent that your (legitimate) critiques concern the original text, I think it is worth staying with the text itself. I understand that the suspicion is that is the aim (I have no idea - I wish it could be clarified).

Mark 8dd57a7382268096...
#57

@tysie: I absolutely love that, and I think it's awesome. Having lots of different communities around the world, created and kept alive by all kinds of different people is one of the most important things right now.

 

In case it has been lost in translation and confusion in the pandemonium that this thread has turned into, do note, that I have not once here said anything negative about any of your efforts, network building, or anything else. In fact I have given it only praise, and seeing how much stuff is going on around Reticulum in NL is awesome. Everyone who's written to me and shared what they're doing will know the same.

 


 

To everyone who might have felt targeted by me (and I can only speak for myself here):

 

The only thing I have pointed towards as being very sketchy, is the "critical infrastructure lab", and I completely stand by this still. I have absolutely zero interest in having any say in how any of you govern your own projects and communities - that is none of my business.

 

Exactly as it is none of Peter Dunajcsik's (and his "lab's") business to attempt to govern the Reticulum project, the development and evolution of the protocol, or anything related to it.

 

This thread has devolved into what - to me - looks like a complete avalanche of misunderstandings of where the criticism was directed, and that some people with completely good intentions felt targeted, or not appreciated.

 

If you are not associated with Peter Dunajcsik, or the "lab", I think I can pretty confidently say, that nobody here has pointed any fingers at you. At least, that is true for myself.

 

Even if you are associated with it, I'd simply caution you to be very careful, and think about how exactly you are involving yourself with that "project". Those of us who have been here from the beginning have the full history, and we've seen what's been going on, both in front of the curtain, and occasionally behind it.

 


 

Lastly, to you @flok, I have no idea what the hell that message is supposed to mean. Take it easy, man, and tone down the anxiety a bit. I've done this for more than a decade.

 

As life has proven so far, I am perfectly capable of not dying, and it is not something I am planning on doing, for any sort of foreseeable future.

 

If having a bit of rough time sometimes sounds too much for you, I can assure you that you are not one to have opinions on who should be responsible in a project like this. It's not a fun game or a weekend activity. It's a life commitment, and that is how I have always been treating it.

 

Maybe take the fact that I've managed to almost single-handedly create this technology on (often a lot less than) $1400 a month, while continuously dealing with more polemics and batshit insane stuff than you can imagine, as a pretty darned good indication, that it's probably a pretty decent idea to have exactly someone like me managing the core protocol and development for now, and probably the next five to ten years as well.

 

I can assure you that I am not going to hand over any sort of decision making or core responsibilities to anyone, unless they have proven beyond any trace of doubt, that they are capable of handling something like that. And very few people are.

 

That takes years of the same level of commitment and work that I have put in myself. Show me that, and I'll begin to cautiously consider. If you can't, meh.

 

It does not help to pile in a bunch of "AIs", committees with good intentions, and eager open source developers who really just wants to contribute to something. That will, with absolute certainty, fuck everything up completely. That will only put more needless work on my shoulders, not less, as recent and past events have very clearly demonstrated.

 

What would make everything insanely easy, would be if I could just focus on the actual development, evolution and design of this entire system, and not deal with constant crap like critical governance laboratories and urgent opinions of everyone under the sun. Holy fuck - you should see what could happen. That is what is draining, not the actual creating and managing.

 

Have I not done enough for you to trust me in this? Have I not created this, maintained, developed it and actually made it real? Have I not solved hundreds of more or less insane technical challenges, and actually gotten it right, time and time again?

 

Can you point me to someone else who could actually have done so, in reality? If so, and they have the skills, and can commit themself in the same way, I'll be happy to bring them on, after a three-year apprenticeship.

 

If not: Attain some fucking respect, and leave me to do what I do best.

 

If you cannot understand or appreciate my choice of words towards you here, I have nothing more to say to you. If you can take this standing up and maybe realize you've had your head a wee bit too far up your own ass for a while now, we're all good. Otherwise, get out of here, right now.

This thread is locked. No new replies can be posted.

Quote
Copied to clipboard